| Round 1 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 1 | Iron City Maulers | Aaron Rodgers | QB01 |
| 2 | Team Whitey | Tom Brady | QB02 |
| 3 | Stumps | Drew Brees | QB03 |
| 4 | Hess's Hogs | Arian Foster | RB01 |
| 5 | Superbowl Bound | Ray Rice | RB02 |
| 6 | Drive-By Snowman | Calvin Johnson | WR01 |
| 7 | Golden Boys | LeSean McCoy | RB03 |
| 8 | Whiskey Rebellion | Matthew Stafford | QB04 |
| 9 | US Americans | Darren McFadden | RB04 |
| 10 | Glory Holes | DeMarco Murray | RB05 |
| 11 | Brighton Bruisers | Chris Johnson | RB06 |
| 12 | Team Repeat | Cam Newton | QB05 |
| Round 2 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 13 | Team Repeat | Matt Forte | RB07 |
| 14 | Brighton Bruisers | Eli Manning | QB06 |
| 15 | Glory Holes | Tony Romo | QB07 |
| 16 | US Americans | Jimmy Graham | WR02 |
| 17 | Whiskey Rebellion | Fred Jackson | RB08 |
| 18 | Golden Boys | Matt Ryan | QB08 |
| 19 | Drive-By Snowman | Andre Johnson | WR03 |
| 20 | Superbowl Bound | Julio Jones | WR04 |
| 21 | Hess's Hogs | Peyton Manning | QB09 |
| 22 | Stumps | Maurice Jones-Drew | RB09 |
| 23 | Team Whitey | Larry Fitzgerald | WR05 |
| 24 | Iron City Maulers | Victor Cruz | WR06 |
| Round 3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 25 | Drive-By Snowman | Doug Martin | RB10 |
| 26 | Stumps | Rob Gronkowski | WR07 |
| 27 | Brighton Bruisers | Brandon Marshall | WR08 |
| 28 | Golden Boys | Wes Welker | WR09 |
| 29 | Hess's Hogs | Roddy White | WR10 |
| 30 | Superbowl Bound | Trent Richardson | RB11 |
| 31 | Iron City Maulers | Marshawn Lynch | RB12 |
| 32 | US Americans | Philip Rivers | QB10 |
| 33 | Glory Holes | Dez Bryant | WR11 |
| 34 | Team Whitey | Adrian Peterson | RB13 |
| 35 | Team Repeat | Jamaal Charles | RB14 |
| 36 | Whiskey Rebellion | Greg Jennings | WR12 |
| Round 4 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 37 | Whiskey Rebellion | Hakeem Nicks | WR13 |
| 38 | Team Repeat | Ryan Mathews | RB15 |
| 39 | Team Whitey | A.J. Green | WR14 |
| 40 | Glory Holes | Darren Sproles | RB16 |
| 41 | US Americans | Eric Decker | WR15 |
| 42 | Iron City Maulers | Michael Turner | RB17 |
| 43 | Superbowl Bound | Marques Colston | WR16 |
| 44 | Hess's Hogs | Steven Jackson | RB18 |
| 45 | Golden Boys | Ahmad Bradshaw | RB19 |
| 46 | Brighton Bruisers | Jordy Nelson | WR17 |
| 47 | Stumps | Reggie Bush | RB20 |
| 48 | Drive-By Snowman | Michael Vick | QB11 |
| Round 5 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 49 | Brighton Bruisers | Frank Gore | RB21 |
| 50 | Team Repeat | Steve Smith | WR18 |
| 51 | US Americans | Willis McGahee | RB22 |
| 52 | Hess's Hogs | Antonio Brown | WR19 |
| 53 | Superbowl Bound | Jay Cutler | QB12 |
| 54 | Whiskey Rebellion | BenJarvus Green-Ellis | RB23 |
| 55 | Golden Boys | Matt Schaub | QB13 |
| 56 | Glory Holes | Mike Wallace | WR20 |
| 57 | Iron City Maulers | Peyton Hillis | RB24 |
| 58 | Stumps | Percy Harvin | WR21 |
| 59 | Team Whitey | Cedric Benson | RB25 |
| 60 | Drive-By Snowman | Kevin Smith | RB26 |
| Round 6 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 61 | Drive-By Snowman | Ben Roethlisberger | QB14 |
| 62 | Team Whitey | Roy Helu | RB27 |
| 63 | Stumps | Jeremy Maclin | WR22 |
| 64 | Iron City Maulers | Demaryius Thomas | WR23 |
| 65 | Glory Holes | Ben Tate | RB28 |
| 66 | Golden Boys | DeSean Jackson | WR24 |
| 67 | Whiskey Rebellion | David Wilson | RB29 |
| 68 | Superbowl Bound | Ryan Williams | RB30 |
| 69 | Hess's Hogs | Robert Griffin III | QB15 |
| 70 | US Americans | Stevan Ridley | RB31 |
| 71 | Team Repeat | Vincent Jackson | WR25 |
| 72 | Brighton Bruisers | Antonio Gates | WR26 |
| Round 7 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 73 | Brighton Bruisers | Miles Austin | WR27 |
| 74 | Drive-By Snowman | Jonathan Stewart | RB32 |
| 75 | Glory Holes | Dwayne Bowe | WR28 |
| 76 | Hess's Hogs | Donald Brown | RB33 |
| 77 | Iron City Maulers | Carson Palmer | QB16 |
| 78 | Team Repeat | Pierre Garcon | WR29 |
| 79 | Superbowl Bound | Stevie Johnson | WR30 |
| 80 | Golden Boys | Brandon Lloyd | WR31 |
| 81 | US Americans | Reggie Wayne | WR32 |
| 82 | Stumps | C.J. Spiller | RB34 |
| 83 | Team Whitey | Jared Allen | DF01 |
| 84 | Whiskey Rebellion | Andrew Luck | QB17 |
| Round 8 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 85 | Whiskey Rebellion | Russell Wilson | QB18 |
| 86 | Team Whitey | DeMarcus Ware | DF02 |
| 87 | Stumps | Clay Matthews | DF03 |
| 88 | US Americans | Ryan Fitzpatrick | QB19 |
| 89 | Golden Boys | Shonn Greene | RB35 |
| 90 | Superbowl Bound | Jake Locker | QB20 |
| 91 | Team Repeat | Kenny Britt | WR33 |
| 92 | Iron City Maulers | Sebastian Janikowski | PK01 |
| 93 | Hess's Hogs | Torrey Smith | WR34 |
| 94 | Glory Holes | Ronnie Hillman | RB36 |
| 95 | Drive-By Snowman | David Akers | PK02 |
| 96 | Brighton Bruisers | DeAngelo Williams | RB37 |
| Round 9 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 97 | Iron City Maulers | LaMarr Woodley | DF04 |
| 98 | Stumps | Josh Freeman | QB21 |
| 99 | Team Whitey | Toby Gerhart | RB38 |
| 100 | Hess's Hogs | Denarius Moore | WR35 |
| 101 | Superbowl Bound | Jason Pierre-Paul | DF05 |
| 102 | Drive-By Snowman | Malcom Floyd | WR36 |
| 103 | Golden Boys | Charles Woodson | DF06 |
| 104 | Whiskey Rebellion | Aaron Hernandez | WR37 |
| 105 | US Americans | Michael Bush | RB39 |
| 106 | Glory Holes | Vernon Davis | WR38 |
| 107 | Brighton Bruisers | Mark Ingram | RB40 |
| 108 | Team Repeat | Mikel LeShoure | RB41 |
| Round 10 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 109 | Team Repeat | Joe Flacco | QB22 |
| 110 | Brighton Bruisers | Alex Smith | QB23 |
| 111 | Glory Holes | Mario Williams | DF07 |
| 112 | US Americans | Matt Prater | PK03 |
| 113 | Whiskey Rebellion | Alfred Morris | RB42 |
| 114 | Golden Boys | Lardarius Webb | DF08 |
| 115 | Drive-By Snowman | Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie | DF09 |
| 116 | Superbowl Bound | Rob Bironas | PK04 |
| 117 | Hess's Hogs | Jacquizz Rodgers | RB43 |
| 118 | Team Whitey | Robert Meachem | WR39 |
| 119 | Stumps | Chris Long | DF10 |
| 120 | Iron City Maulers | Darrius Heyward-Bey | WR40 |
| Round 11 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 121 | Drive-By Snowman | Aldon Smith | DF11 |
| 122 | Stumps | Julius Peppers | DF12 |
| 123 | Brighton Bruisers | Mike Nugent | PK05 |
| 124 | Golden Boys | Cliff Avril | DF13 |
| 125 | Hess's Hogs | Matt Cassel | QB24 |
| 126 | Superbowl Bound | Von Miller | DF14 |
| 127 | Iron City Maulers | Andy Dalton | QB25 |
| 128 | US Americans | Elvis Dumervil | DF15 |
| 129 | Glory Holes | Dan Bailey | PK06 |
| 130 | Team Whitey | Blaine Gabbert | QB26 |
| 131 | Team Repeat | Garrett Hartley | PK07 |
| 132 | Whiskey Rebellion | Nate Kaeding | PK08 |
| Round 12 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 133 | Whiskey Rebellion | Nate Washington | WR41 |
| 134 | Team Repeat | Patrick Peterson | DF16 |
| 135 | Team Whitey | Sidney Rice | WR42 |
| 136 | Glory Holes | Kyle Orton | QB27 |
| 137 | US Americans | Greg Little | WR43 |
| 138 | Iron City Maulers | James Harrison | DF17 |
| 139 | Superbowl Bound | Sam Bradford | QB28 |
| 140 | Hess's Hogs | Jason Babin | DF18 |
| 141 | Golden Boys | Kendall Hunter | RB44 |
| 142 | Brighton Bruisers | Chris Houston | DF19 |
| 143 | Stumps | Dan Carpenter | PK09 |
| 144 | Drive-By Snowman | Eric Weddle | DF20 |
| Round 13 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 145 | Brighton Bruisers | Tamba Hali | DF21 |
| 146 | Team Repeat | Chris Clemons | DF22 |
| 147 | US Americans | Trent Cole | DF23 |
| 148 | Hess's Hogs | Osi Umenyiora | DF24 |
| 149 | Superbowl Bound | Robbie Gould | PK10 |
| 150 | Whiskey Rebellion | Justin Tuck | DF25 |
| 151 | Golden Boys | Billy Cundiff | PK11 |
| 152 | Glory Holes | Brandon Carr | DF26 |
| 153 | Iron City Maulers | Rashard Mendenhall | RB45 |
| 154 | Stumps | Jason Witten | WR44 |
| 155 | Team Whitey | Brian Orakpo | DF27 |
| 156 | Drive-By Snowman | Shane Vereen | RB46 |
| Round 14 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 157 | Drive-By Snowman | Shaun Hill | QB29 |
| 158 | Team Whitey | Shayne Graham | PK12 |
| 159 | Stumps | Cameron Wake | DF28 |
| 160 | Iron City Maulers | Titus Young | WR45 |
| 161 | Glory Holes | Cortland Finnegan | DF29 |
| 162 | Golden Boys | Jermichael Finley | WR46 |
| 163 | Whiskey Rebellion | Connor Barwin | DF30 |
| 164 | Superbowl Bound | Charles Johnson | DF31 |
| 165 | Hess's Hogs | Jason Hanson | PK13 |
| 166 | US Americans | Brandon Browner | DF32 |
| 167 | Team Repeat | Melvin Ingram | DF33 |
| 168 | Brighton Bruisers | Mason Crosby | PK14 |
| Round 15 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 169 | Brighton Bruisers | Tramon Williams | DF34 |
| 170 | Drive-By Snowman | Michael Crabtree | WR47 |
| 171 | Glory Holes | DeAngelo Hall | DF35 |
| 172 | Hess's Hogs | Ryan Kerrigan | DF36 |
| 173 | Iron City Maulers | Troy Polamalu | DF37 |
| 174 | Team Repeat | Christian Ponder | QB30 |
| 175 | Superbowl Bound | Dwight Freeney | DF38 |
| 176 | Golden Boys | Stephen Gostkowski | PK15 |
| 177 | US Americans | Asante Samuel | DF39 |
| 178 | Stumps | Justin Tucker | PK16 |
| 179 | Team Whitey | Ryan Mallett | QB31 |
| 180 | Whiskey Rebellion | Jairus Byrd | DF40 |
| Round 16 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 181 | Whiskey Rebellion | Alex Henery | PK17 |
| 182 | Team Whitey | Matt Bryant | PK18 |
| 183 | Stumps | Daniel Thomas | RB47 |
| 184 | US Americans | Lawrence Tynes | PK19 |
| 185 | Golden Boys | Luke McCown | QB32 |
| 186 | Superbowl Bound | Beanie Wells | RB48 |
| 187 | Team Repeat | Antonio Cromartie | DF41 |
| 188 | Iron City Maulers | Kamerion Wimbley | DF42 |
| 189 | Hess's Hogs | Ed Reed | DF43 |
| 190 | Glory Holes | Blair Walsh | PK20 |
| 191 | Drive-By Snowman | Rian Lindell | PK21 |
| 192 | Brighton Bruisers | Graham Harrell | QB33 |
| Round 17 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 193 | Iron City Maulers | Connor Barth | PK22 |
| 194 | Stumps | Chase Daniel | QB34 |
| 195 | Team Whitey | Carlos Rogers | DF44 |
| 196 | Hess's Hogs | Steven Hauschka | PK23 |
| 197 | Superbowl Bound | Justin Blackmon | WR48 |
| 198 | Drive-By Snowman | Nate Clements | DF45 |
| 199 | Golden Boys | Tommy Kelly | DF46 |
| 200 | Whiskey Rebellion | Darrelle Revis | DF47 |
| 201 | US Americans | Billy Volek | QB35 |
| 202 | Glory Holes | Mark Sanchez | QB36 |
| 203 | Brighton Bruisers | Nick Barnett | DF48 |
| 204 | Team Repeat | Greg Zuerlein | PK24 |
| Round 18 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| # | Team | Player | Pos |
| 205 | Team Repeat | Isaac Redman | RB49 |
| 206 | Brighton Bruisers | Owen Daniels | WR49 |
| 207 | Glory Holes | Jon Baldwin | WR50 |
| 208 | US Americans | Taiwan Jones | RB50 |
| 209 | Whiskey Rebellion | Brandon Pettigrew | WR51 |
| 210 | Golden Boys | Mario Manningham | WR52 |
| 211 | Drive-By Snowman | Rashad Jennings | RB51 |
| 212 | Superbowl Bound | Ronnie Brown | RB52 |
| 213 | Hess's Hogs | Randy Moss | WR53 |
| 214 | Team Whitey | LeGarrette Blount | RB53 |
| 215 | Stumps | Santana Moss | WR54 |
| 216 | Iron City Maulers | Jonathan Dwyer | RB54 |